Reviewer Instructions

Cards

Do

  • Complete and submit your conflict of interest form and/or disclose all potential conflicts. Conflict mays include:
    • Serving as PI or key personnel on an application under review
    • The potential to receive a direct or indirect financial benefit
    • An employee of the PI or institution of an application
    • Applications that include professional associates or personal relationships
    • Appearance of a conflict
  • Keep all grant applications and materials strictly confidential
  • Notify the appropriate individual if you discover additional conflicts once you begin your review
  • Immediately disclose any inappropriate communications such as request for a favorable review
  • Leave the room prior to any discussion for an application in which you are in conflict
  • Destroy or return all documents as instructed or required

Don't

  • Discuss the grant application with anyone outside of the review panel – before, during or after the meeting
  • Discuss the grant applications with review panel members before the meeting
  • Bring up concerns of scientific misconduct during the review meeting, discuss them privately with the
    appropriate person (e.g., SRO for NIH)
  • Mention previous scores received by the application or compare an application to another
  • Discuss funding, budget or administrative issues
Top